1804: The Amendment That Fixed the Tie Problem
After the deadlock of 1800, when Jefferson and Burr finished tied at 73 electoral votes and the House needed 36 ballots plus decisive intervention from Hamilton to choose a president, the Twelfth Amendment separated presidential and vice presidential votes. The election of 1804 was the first test, and it ran smoothly.
Jefferson, riding the Louisiana Purchase and prosperity, crushed Charles Cotesworth Pinckney 162 to 14. The election database walks the amendment fight and the ballot math, pairing 1804 with the contested 1796 race that first exposed the flaw.
A quiet election can still be a turning point, and the data shows why..
Back to Blog